No Result
View All Results
Reserve & National Guard
SUBSCRIBE FREE
No Result
View All Results
Reserve & National Guard
SUBSCRIBE FREE
Reserve & National Guard

‘Stretched too thin’: Guard members have mixed reactions to unionization efforts

Will Martin
by Will Martin
March 15, 2022
Unionization

A Texas Guardsmen and a Customs and Border Patrol agent discuss the lay of the land April 10 on the shores of the Rio Grande River in Starr County, Texas as part of the federal call-up to the Texas Mexico border. Photo courtesy the Texas Military Department/DVIDS

Duty calls often for National Guard soldiers and airmen. Between combat tours abroad and emergencies at home, most guard members far exceed their recruiters’ promises of weekend drills and two weeks of annual training.

“Service members are stretched too thin,” said a senior California Army National Guard officer, speaking on condition of anonymity. “And if you’re low-ranking, you don’t really have a voice. If your professional life is suffering from constant mobilizations, your only voice is to not reenlist.”

But some Guard members are exploring another path to advocacy: unionization.

In recent months, Guard members in a handful of states have taken the unprecedented step of exploring union support, hoping to curb the frequency of stateside missions. Law prohibits Guard members on federal orders from unionizing. But in January, Department of Justice lawyers stated in court filings that such restrictions don’t apply to guardsmen on state orders.

The National Guard Bureau deferred to the Justice Department as the authority on the matter, and it remains to be seen how the push to unionize will flesh out at the state level. As the situation evolves, reactions among Guard members are mixed.

“I can understand why there would be a push for unions among some troops,” said a senior Texas Air National Guard officer, also speaking on condition of anonymity. “The biggest complaint I’ve encountered is they’re not given a deadline on when they’re coming home or their orders are repeatedly extended, often on short notice.”

Unionization efforts in Texas

In Texas, the unionization effort centers on Operation Lone Star, the state’s massive border mission. In March 2021, Gov. Greg Abbot declared a state of emergency and mobilized the National Guard to slow illegal border crossings. In short order, about 10,000 Guard members were called to full-time service.

RELATED: National Guard activations continue to fill gaps in 2022

“I think the media reports [about conditions on the border mission] were overblown,” said the same Texas Air Guard officer, referring to allegations of chronic pay issues and deplorable living conditions. “In my experience, the work environment is actually pretty manageable. That said, their whole life is often in limbo, not only for them, but also for their civilian employers. We have people leaving [the Texas Guard] left and right.”

Rather than depart in protest, however, some Guard members approached the Texas State Employees Union. Its president, Judy Lugo, confirmed for Reserve & National Guard Magazine that TSEU is working with members of the state’s Army National Guard: “All Texas State Employees are invited to join, participate and enact change: this includes the proud men and women of the Texas Army National Guard.”

But according to the Texas Military Department, unionization isn’t an option for its members.

Unionization
A soldier from the Texas National Guard scans the shores of the Rio Grande River in Starr County, Texas April 10 as part of the federal call-up to the Texas-Mexico border. Photo courtesy Texas Military Department/DVIDS

“Service members should not be misled by union agitators into believing that Texas law allows them to engage in collective bargaining. It does not,” said Army Col. Rita Holton, Public Affairs Director for the Texas Military Department, referencing Chapter 617 of the Texas Government Code.

Holton also emphasized that the Texas Guard is working to remedy concerns as they arise, such as pay challenges and hardship requests. Military leadership, she said, is proactive in addressing concerns from the field.

“My vision of unions is that role is really what military leadership is for, especially senior NCOs,” said Army Master Sgt. Jessica Espinosa, echoing the stance of Texas Guard leadership. 

Espinosa, who now serves with the Army Reserve’s 416th Theater Engineer Command, in Darien, Illinois, mobilized for about two years as a junior NCO with the California Army National Guard in support of its border missions in 2010-12.

“There was definitely some strain, especially on relationships, but by and large, it went smoothly,” said Espinosa. “The leadership knew these were people with real lives outside the Guard, not just personnel supporting a mission.”

This story was written Will Martin. He served in the Army National Guard and Air Force Reserve for 21 years before retiring in 2019.

Read comments
Tags: National GuardTexas National GuardUnionUnionization
Will Martin

Will Martin

Will Martin is an award-winning writer with more than 20 years of journalism and public affairs experience. An Iraq War veteran, he served in the Army National Guard and Air Force Reserve for 21 years before retiring in 2019. His writing passions include military and veterans issues, sports, and social justice.

Related Posts

Country music icon enlists, wants to inspire next generation of recruits

by Jessica Manfre
2 weeks ago
0
Staff Sgt. Craig Morgan took the oath of enlistment on the stage of the Grand Ole Opry. CREDIT: © Grand Ole Opry, photos by Chris Hollo

Army veteran and country music star Craig Morgan surprised an audience this summer by taking the oath of enlistment during...

Read more

Military provides disaster relief assistance on Maui

by AmeriForce Exclusive
1 month ago
0
disaster relief

The Defense Department continues to support disaster relief efforts related to the devastating wildfire on Maui, Hawaii.

Read more

Army Reserve education benefits collapse halts fall semester enrollments

by Military.com
1 month ago
0
U.S. Army Reserve soldier fires a M240B automatic machine gun during a live fire range qualification on Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst, New Jersey, July 18, 2023. Photo by Spc. Britton Spencer

The Army Reserve ran out of money to cover tuition for its soldiers & is scrambling to reallocate money ahead of the...

Read more

EXCLUSIVE: Incoming Sergeant Major of the Marine Corps talks value of reserves, future of force

by Kari Williams
2 months ago
0
MARFORRES

Sgt. Maj. Carlos Ruiz never served in the MARFORRES, but jokingly hoped he would be confused for doing just that.

Read more

‘Life-changing’ debt-relief extension act would continue assisting reserve component

by AmeriForce Exclusive
2 months ago
0
Debt relief

Guardsmen and reservists facing bankruptcy will continue to get a reprieve, should an extension to a debt relief act be...

Read more

President Biden activated the Individual Ready Reserve

by WeAreTheMighty
2 months ago
0
(U.S. Marine Corps)

On July 13, 2023, President Joe Biden ordered the Selective Reserve and certain members of the IRR to active duty.

Read more

Ads

Let's get social

The RNG Drill

News delivered directly to your inbox

Let's connect!

ABOUT US

  • OUR STORY
  • OUR TEAM
  • OUR WRITERS

MAGAZINE

  • GET PRINT
  • GET DIGITAL
  • GET THE NEWSLETTER

ADVERTISE

  • GET OUR MEDIA KIT
  • PUBLISHER’S STATEMENT

SUBMISSIONS

  • SUBMIT YOUR STORY

Never miss out on the latest stories.

© 2021 Reserve & National Guard by AmeriForce. Privacy Policy | Terms | Site by Swiss Commerce

Thank you for your interest in The Reserve & National Guard Magazine!

Thank you for your interest in The Reserve & National Guard Magazine!

No Result
View All Results
  • NEWS
  • YOUR CAREER
    • UNIT TRAINING
    • DEPLOYMENT
    • PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
    • RECRUITING & RETENTION
    • ENTREPRENEUR
    • TRANSITION
  • EDUCATION
  • MILITARY LIFE
    • MILITARY SPOUSES
    • MILITARY KIDS
    • PARENTING
  • OFF DUTY
    • ENTERTAINMENT
    • TRAVEL
  • HEALTH
    • FITNESS
    • MEDICINE
    • MENTAL HEALTH
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
  • HISTORY
  • MONEY
    • PERSONAL FINANCE
    • BENEFITS
  • GET THE MAGAZINE
    • PRINT MAGAZINES
    • DIGITAL MAGAZINES
    • GET THE NEWSLETTER
  • ABOUT US
    • MEET OUR TEAM
    • OUR AUTHORS
    • ADVERTISE WITH US
    • SUBMIT YOUR STORY
    • PITCH US
    • CONTACT

© 2022 Reserve & National Guard by AmeriForce. Site by SCBW