No Result
View All Results
Reserve & National Guard
SUBSCRIBE FREE
No Result
View All Results
Reserve & National Guard
SUBSCRIBE FREE
Reserve & National Guard

Selective Service Commission recommends elimination of male-only registration

Matthew Feehan
by Matthew Feehan
April 2, 2020
Selective Service

The Commission held a series of meetings in 2019 on the topic of selective service.

Chairman Joseph J. Heck, Vice chair for Military Service, Debra Wada, Vice Chair for National and Public Service, and their fellow commissioners comprising published their final report to Congress.

In the Commission’s 255-page report, a plethora of important recommendations are made to Congress ranging from improving agencies’ hiring tools for military members by avoiding avoid keyword-based resume reviews and self-assessments to implementing a modern talent-management system across the Federal Government.

Most notably, in historic fashion, the Commission has recommended to Congress, “that Congress amend the [Military Selective Service Act] to eliminate male-only registration and expand draft eligibility to all individuals of the applicable age cohort.” [See Report at 139.]

This is just the beginning.

Most importantly, this is a recommendation, nothing more. The Military Selective Service Act still stands on the male-only language U.S. District Judge Gray Miller of the Southern District of Texas has ruled unconstitutional in a declaratory judgment.

See “Federal judge deems all-male draft unconstitutional“

With the Commission’s years of hard work forever memorialized in this historic report, the baton has been returned to Congress for it to decide whether to amend this controversial law. Just as a commander may ask for Courses of Action (COA) to be drafted in order to aid her or him in their military decision-making process, Congress has now been given an extraordinary COA or, in this case, a report to aid its important task ahead.

Throughout the development of its report, the Commission heard 68 panelists across 14 public hearings in 2019. Among the many panelists heard, Mr. Doug Bandow, Senior Fellow, Cato Institute, provided testimony. In addition, Dr. William Galston, Ezra K. Zilkha Chair and Senior Fellow, Brookings Institution, provided testimony for the Commission to consider. Many civilian and military professionals, such as Major General John Evans, U.S. Army, Representative, U.S. Army Training and Doctrine Command provided critical and unique insight into this development. Thus, the Commission’s recommendations to Congress were not created in a vacuum.

What’s next?

If Congress does successfully amend the MSSA to remove the law’s male-only language and replace it with more inclusive language, the biggest hurdle will be educating the public. Unsurprisingly, the Commission chose educating the public as the its first recommendation.

To effectively educate the American public on national and public service, the Commission recommended that Congress appropriate $450 million per year for civic education and service learning, which, given the current state of financial affairs in our Country, may be a challenge for Congress. [See Report at page 124.]

However, with a dwindling population of military veterans in Congress combined with an arguably growing disconnect between civilian U.S. Citizens and their military, educating young Americans on the role of public service is long overdue.

NCFM v. Selective Service System

Mr. Harry Crouch, president of the National Coalition For Men, a non-profit men’s rights organization that filed a lawsuit against the Selective Service System in 2013, said, “the Commission has many good suggestions.” He further stated, “my principal concern is that whatever system they choose, it’s there for everyone.”

Responding to whether Mr. Crouch agrees with the Commission’s recommendation to better fund civics education in our country, he stated, “he is excited to hear people talking about civics again.”

Author’s opinion

As a proud stepfather to four daughters and former infantry officer, I echo several Senator’s public concerns, such as Senator Cruz’s, about drafting our daughters into military service. However, I support the Commission’s recommendations to Congress entirely and wholeheartedly.

I am proud to say that my daughters can recognize and explain the meaning behind the colors of the Vietnam Service Medal or the purple heart when they see them during their days. I make it a point to direct their attention to unique military-things throughout the day and explain the different roles each branch of our government plays. As such, like many complex and delicate issues, we — as Americans — tackle, many can be solved through education. Like many Americans, I will be waiting to hear Congress’s response its Commission’s report when our Nation roars back from this current crisis.

Be on the lookout for a more in-depth article addressing this historic report and the many legal complexities that will arise as we head further down this uncharted road together.

Read comments
Tags: Harry CrouchNational Coalition for MenSelective ServiceSelective Service CommissionSenator Ted Cruz
Matthew Feehan

Matthew Feehan

Matthew Feehan is a former infantry officer with the Massachusetts Army National Guard. He served as a boatswain's mate with the United States Coast Guard Reserve, Port Security Unit 301 as an enlisted soldier before he earned his commission from Boston University’s Reserve Officer Training Corps. He later served as a summer law intern for the Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review. Most recently, he deployed to the Northern Sinai in support of the Multinational Force and Observers mission as a force protection platoon leader. As a graduate of Western New England University School of Law, he is focusing his research and writing on service members’ rights within academia. Specifically, he seeks to expand the standard legal protections offered to service members by the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994 to service members enrolled in academic programs.

Related Posts

Army medic receives EMT certification through the military

by Christopher Adams
3 days ago
0
Ambulance standing in night traffic at a motor vehicle accident in early winter, Roseburg Oregon

Spc. Trevor George, who serves in the Minnesota National Guard, trained and served as an Army medic and currently works...

Read more

Country music icon enlists, wants to inspire next generation of recruits

by Jessica Manfre
2 weeks ago
0
Staff Sgt. Craig Morgan took the oath of enlistment on the stage of the Grand Ole Opry. CREDIT: © Grand Ole Opry, photos by Chris Hollo

Army veteran and country music star Craig Morgan surprised an audience this summer by taking the oath of enlistment during...

Read more

Award-winning career counselor puts his soldiers first

by Christopher Adams
3 weeks ago
0
career counselor

For Sgt. 1st Class Antoni Bukowski, receiving the Army Reserve’s 2023 Career Counselor of the Year honor felt like winning...

Read more

Military provides disaster relief assistance on Maui

by AmeriForce Exclusive
1 month ago
0
disaster relief

The Defense Department continues to support disaster relief efforts related to the devastating wildfire on Maui, Hawaii.

Read more

Chief master sergeant aims to ‘make things better’ for reservists

by Kari Williams
1 month ago
0
Air Force Reserve

One of the newest members of the Air Force Reserve’s advisory council hopes to bring a focus on mental health...

Read more

Army Reserve education benefits collapse halts fall semester enrollments

by Military.com
1 month ago
0
U.S. Army Reserve soldier fires a M240B automatic machine gun during a live fire range qualification on Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst, New Jersey, July 18, 2023. Photo by Spc. Britton Spencer

The Army Reserve ran out of money to cover tuition for its soldiers & is scrambling to reallocate money ahead of the...

Read more

Ads

Let's get social

The RNG Drill

News delivered directly to your inbox

Let's connect!

ABOUT US

  • OUR STORY
  • OUR TEAM
  • OUR WRITERS

MAGAZINE

  • GET PRINT
  • GET DIGITAL
  • GET THE NEWSLETTER

ADVERTISE

  • GET OUR MEDIA KIT
  • PUBLISHER’S STATEMENT

SUBMISSIONS

  • SUBMIT YOUR STORY

Never miss out on the latest stories.

© 2021 Reserve & National Guard by AmeriForce. Privacy Policy | Terms | Site by Swiss Commerce

Thank you for your interest in The Reserve & National Guard Magazine!

Thank you for your interest in The Reserve & National Guard Magazine!

No Result
View All Results
  • NEWS
  • YOUR CAREER
    • UNIT TRAINING
    • DEPLOYMENT
    • PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
    • RECRUITING & RETENTION
    • ENTREPRENEUR
    • TRANSITION
  • EDUCATION
  • MILITARY LIFE
    • MILITARY SPOUSES
    • MILITARY KIDS
    • PARENTING
  • OFF DUTY
    • ENTERTAINMENT
    • TRAVEL
  • HEALTH
    • FITNESS
    • MEDICINE
    • MENTAL HEALTH
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
  • HISTORY
  • MONEY
    • PERSONAL FINANCE
    • BENEFITS
  • GET THE MAGAZINE
    • PRINT MAGAZINES
    • DIGITAL MAGAZINES
    • GET THE NEWSLETTER
  • ABOUT US
    • MEET OUR TEAM
    • OUR AUTHORS
    • ADVERTISE WITH US
    • SUBMIT YOUR STORY
    • PITCH US
    • CONTACT

© 2022 Reserve & National Guard by AmeriForce. Site by SCBW