No Result
View All Result
Reserve & National Guard
SUBSCRIBE FREE
No Result
View All Result
Reserve & National Guard
SUBSCRIBE FREE
Reserve & National Guard

Reservist claims he lost his job at NASA due to military leave

By Hope Hodge Seck

Military.com
by Military.com
March 31, 2021

Read the original article on Military.com. Follow Military.com on Twitter. 

A federal appeals court has handed down a win to a commander in the Navy Reserve who claims he was placed on a performance improvement plan and ultimately removed from his NASA position for taking leave to perform his military duties.

The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit ruled March 11 that the Merit Systems Protection Board, an independent agency that evaluates the removal of federal employees, did not correctly evaluate the case of Fernando Santos, who had worked at NASA for 18 years when he was removed from his position in 2018. The court remanded Santos’ case, appealing his removal from his job, back to the board for reconsideration.

Santos, a Navy engineering duty officer with over 20 years of service, had had a distinguished career at NASA, preceded by several years working for the agency as a contractor, according to court summaries. He’d worked as the lead engineer on projects, including the space shuttles Endeavour (OV-105), Atlantis (OV-104), and Discovery (OV-103), and had received NASA’s prestigious Silver Snoopy award, which recognizes exceptional service beyond duty requirements that contributes to mission success. Only 1% of eligible recipients receive the award.

Santos’ career appeared to take a turn, however, in 2017, when he joined the Ground Systems Branch in the Commercial Systems Division of the Engineering Directorate at John F. Kennedy Space Center in Florida as a mechanical engineer. According to Santos’ testimony to the Merit Systems Protection Board, his new supervisor at the job seemed to have a problem with his taking military leave, which he did for up to eight weeks at a time.

“Before the Board, Santos testified that, although he ‘had never had problems with his use of military leave previously, he noticed as the year progressed that [his supervisor] was routinely taking a longer amount of time to approve his use of military leave,'” Circuit Judge Kathleen O’Malley wrote for the court.

Read: West Point grad makes NASA space dreams come true

Santos also claimed that he was held accountable for meetings he missed because he was on leave, including those scheduled after he’d requested the time out. In one case in November 2017, Santos said, he was tasked with compiling a report that required knowledge of a meeting that happened while he was out.

“Although Santos eventually obtained a copy of the meeting minutes and submitted the report, [the supervisor] informed Santos that the report was unsatisfactory and asked another employee to redo Santos’s work,” O’Malley wrote.

In early 2018, Santos received a “Letter of Instruction” regarding proper use of leave and recording work hours, just a day after he’d had another military leave request approved. According to the court’s summary, this was followed by a series of reprimands over the next several months as Santos was held accountable for information shared in meetings held while he was out, and once for a lapsed training that he completed two days after returning from leave.

The cycle culminated, according to the court, with Santos’ supervisor placing him on a performance improvement plan, or PIP, for 45 days. The PIP included 11 assignments and entailed multiple meetings between Santos and his supervisor to evaluate progress. At the end of the period, which also included some military leave, Santos’ performance was deemed to be unacceptable, and he was removed from his job Sept. 26, 2018.

Santos appealed to the board, saying that his firing violated the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act, which protects Guard and reserve members from losing their jobs or facing workplace discrimination because of the requirements of their military duties.

The board considered Santos’ performance while on the PIP and decided that NASA had cause to remove him following that period. But, the court found, it didn’t consider whether Santos had been placed appropriately on the PIP in the first place. It also rejected Santos’ USERRA claim as not being supported by sufficient evidence.

“In reaching this conclusion, the Board concluded that there was no evidence supporting Santos’s claim because [his supervisor] ‘thanked him for his service,’ was ‘very patriotic,’ and did not express to others that Santos took too much military leave,” O’Malley wrote.

While the board has a longstanding practice of not considering pre-PIP performance, the court found that Santos’ situation required that consideration so his claim that the PIP itself was retaliatory could get proper evaluation.

“An agency could establish a PIP in direct retaliation for protected conduct and set up unreasonable expectations in the PIP in the hopes of predicating removal on them without ever being held accountable for the original retaliatory conduct,” the decision stated. “Indeed, these are the circumstances in which the issue of pre-PIP performance would be most relevant.”

The court overturned the board’s original decision in Santos’ case and ordered the board to give further consideration to both the circumstances preceding the PIP and his claims of retaliation under USERRA.

According to Santos’ LinkedIn profile, he stopped working for NASA at the Kennedy Space Center in 2018 but began a new role as senior project manager for NASA based in Wallops Island, Virginia, in January 2020. He did not respond to a message requesting comment on the case.

A spokesperson for the Merit Systems Protection Board told Military.com in a statement that,

“Once the court’s mandate issues, the remanded case will be processed in accordance with the court’s decision.” The board declined further comment on the case.

“NASA fully supports our employees who proudly serve in the reserve components of America’s military,” an agency spokesperson told Military.com in a statement. “It would be inappropriate, however, for NASA to discuss personnel matters.”

— Hope Hodge Seck can be reached at hope.seck@military.com. Follow her on Twitter at @HopeSeck.

Read comments
Tags: Kennedy Space Centermilitary leaveNASANavy ReserveUniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994
Military.com

Military.com

Military.com is proud to serve those who serve our country. Our website enables the millions of Americans with military affinity to access their benefits, advance their careers, enjoy military discounts, and stay connected for life.

Related Posts

AFRC, Mercy hospitals training agreement benefits multiple parties

by Allison Churchill
2 weeks ago
0
Mercy

An agreement between Air Force Reserve Command and Mercy allows reservists in medical fields to train at the Catholic hospital...

Read more

Ohio Guard quietly removed guardsman guilty of making ghost guns last year

by Military.com
2 weeks ago
0
Ice covers the "Minuteman" statue in front of the Ohio Air National Guard Headquarters building, Dec. 20, 2016. (U.S. Air National Guard photo by Tech. Sgt. Joe Harwood\Released)

The Ohio National Guard says it booted a guardsman who was sentenced for making ghost guns from its ranks months...

Read more

National Guard, reserve veterans among IAVA’s advocacy all-stars

by AmeriForce Staff
3 weeks ago
0
IAVA

Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America's (IAVA) All-Star Advocacy Fly-In on Capitol Hill included several reserve component veterans.

Read more

Military services will amend COVID vaccine-refuser records so they aren’t passed over for promotions

by Military.com
3 weeks ago
0
Vaccine

All military services are reworking their policies to adjust separation & promotion records for those who refused the COVID-19 vaccine.

Read more

Space National Guard gets renewed push from lawmakers

by Military.com
4 weeks ago
0
Space National Guard

Lawmakers from both sides of the aisle are once again backing a bill that would create a Space National Guard.

Read more

Ukraine support: Meet the reservists who give the U.S. an ‘unmatched advantage’

by Kari Williams
4 weeks ago
0
Joint Transportation Reserve Unit

The Joint Transportation Reserve Unit of TRANSCOM gives the U.S. and 'unmatched advantage' in the United States' support of Ukraine.

Read more

Ads

Let's get social

The RNG Drill

News delivered directly to your inbox

Let's connect!

ABOUT US

  • OUR STORY
  • OUR TEAM
  • OUR WRITERS

MAGAZINE

  • GET PRINT
  • GET DIGITAL
  • GET THE NEWSLETTER

GET RESOURCES

  • VETERANS TOOLKIT

ADVERTISE

  • GET OUR MEDIA KIT
  • PUBLISHER’S STATEMENT

SUBMISSIONS

  • PITCH US
  • SUBMIT YOUR STORY

Never miss out on the latest stories.

© 2021 Reserve & National Guard by AmeriForce. Privacy Policy | Terms | Site by Swiss Commerce

Thank you for your interest in The Reserve & National Guard Magazine!

Thank you for your interest in The Reserve & National Guard Magazine!

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
  • YOUR CAREER
    • UNIT TRAINING
    • DEPLOYMENT
    • PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
    • RECRUITING & RETENTION
    • ENTREPRENEUR
    • TRANSITION
  • EDUCATION
  • MILITARY LIFE
    • MILITARY SPOUSES
    • MILITARY KIDS
    • PARENTING
  • OFF DUTY
    • ENTERTAINMENT
    • TRAVEL
  • HEALTH
    • FITNESS
    • MEDICINE
    • MENTAL HEALTH
  • SPORTS
  • OPINION
  • HISTORY
  • MONEY
    • PERSONAL FINANCE
    • BENEFITS
  • GET THE MAGAZINE
    • PRINT MAGAZINES
    • DIGITAL MAGAZINES
    • GET THE NEWSLETTER
  • RESOURCES
    • VETERANS TOOLKIT
  • ABOUT US
    • MEET OUR TEAM
    • OUR AUTHORS
    • ADVERTISE WITH US
    • SUBMIT YOUR STORY
    • PITCH US
    • CONTACT

© 2022 Reserve & National Guard by AmeriForce. Site by SCBW

Skip to toolbar
  • About WordPress
    • WordPress.org
    • Documentation
    • Support
    • Feedback
  • AMP
    • View AMP version